Tag Archives: oceania

Will fighting around Ukraine nuclear plant cause another Chernobyl disaster?

The threat of nuclear calamity has hung for months over Russia's war in Ukraine.

Those fears were renewed last week after shelling intensified around the massive Zaporizhzhia nuclear power plant, Europe's largest, which has been under Russian control since March.

Attacks at the complex, which have ramped up as fighting flares in Ukraine's south, have sparked concerns about the spectre of nuclear disaster, leading the United Nation's watchdog and world leaders to demand that a mission be allowed to visit the site and assess the damage.

READ MORE: Prime Minister to make 'diplomatic representations' over release of Bali bomb maker

So just how real is the risk that the fighting poses?

Nuclear experts are keen to defuse some of the more alarmist warnings, explaining that the main threat is closest to the plant itself and doesn't justify Europe-wide alerts. Experts are particularly wary of any comparisons to the Chernobyl disaster, a repeat of which is incredibly unlikely, they said.

"It's not very likely that this plant will be damaged," Leon Cizelj, president of the European Nuclear Society, told CNN.

"In the very unlikely case that it is, the radioactive problem would mostly affect Ukrainians that live nearby," rather than spreading throughout eastern Europe as was the case with Chernobyl, he said.

"If we used past experience, Fukushima could be a comparison of the worst-case scenario," Cizelj added, referring to the serious but more localised meltdown at the Japanese plant in 2011. The most pressing dangers would be faced by Ukrainians living in the vicinity of the plant, which is on the banks of the Dnipro River, south of Zaporizhzhia city, and by the Ukrainian staff who are still working there.

Malcolm Davis, a senior analyst at the Australian Strategic Policy Institute, said Russia could be using control of the nuclear plant as a means of coercion during the conflict, by threatening to escalate the fighting

Here's what you need to know about the clashes at Zaporizhzhia nuclear plant, and what their implications could be.

READ MORE: Finnish PM denies drug intake during 'wild' dance party

What's happening at the Zaporizhzhia plant?

Shellfire at the Zaporizhzhia plant in recent weeks has damaged a dry storage facility – where casks of spent nuclear fuel are kept at the plant – as well as radiation monitoring detectors, according to Energoatom, Ukraine's state-run nuclear power company.

On August 5, several explosions near the electrical switchboard caused a power shutdown and one reactor was disconnected from the electrical grid, the United Nations' International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) chief said. Rafael Mariano Grossi told the UN Security Council that the situation had deteriorated "to the point of being very alarming."

Kyiv has repeatedly accused Russian forces of storing heavy weaponry inside the complex and using it as cover to launch attacks, knowing that Ukraine can't return fire without risking hitting one of the plant's six reactors. Moscow, meanwhile, has claimed Ukrainian troops are targeting the site. Both sides have tried to point the finger at the other for threatening nuclear terrorism.

Calls are growing for an IAEA mission to be allowed to visit the complex. But fighting has continued despite the concern.

On Tuesday, Ukrainian authorities said the town of Nikopol, across the Dnipro River from the plant, had again come under rocket fire again.

"The shelling has threatened the safety of operators working on the site, and there have been reports that a worker was hit by shrapnel and taken to hospital," Henry Preston, a communications manager at the London-based World Nuclear Association, told CNN.

He called the workers' professionalism under occupation "remarkable" and the use of an operational power plant for military activities "unconscionable."

READ MORE: How 'audacious' Ukrainian attacks in Crimea threaten Putin war goals

How secure are the plant's nuclear reactors?

Modern nuclear power plants are extremely well reinforced to prevent damage from all kinds of attacks, such as earthquakes, and Zaporizhzhia is no exception.

"Like all nuclear power plants, Zaporizhzhia contains various redundant safety systems, which under normal circumstances are highly effective," James​ Acton, the co‑director of the Nuclear Policy Program at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, told CNN.

"The problem is that nuclear power plants are not designed for war zones and, under plausible circumstances, all these systems could fail," he added.

The plant's six reactors – only two of which are currently functioning – are protected by steel and metres-thick concrete casing.

"Random shelling cannot really destroy this, it would be really improbable," Cizelj said.

Were the reactors to come under attack by deliberate, targeted shelling, the risk would increase – but even that would require a "very, very skilled" operation, he said.

While Ukraine is not a member of the European Union, Cizelj told CNN that he expected Zaporizhzhia's precautions to be "comparable" to that of EU countries, where plants must adhere to strict nuclear safety rules.

READ MORE: Starbucks imitator takes over chain's old stores in Russia

Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant in Okuma town.

What is the worst-case scenario?

Nuclear plants use a number of auxiliary safety systems, such as diesel generators and external grid connections, to keep reactors cool.

Zaporizhzhia also uses a spray pond, a reservoir in which hot water from inside the plant is cooled. If those systems failed, then the nuclear reactor would heat up swiftly, triggering a nuclear meltdown. That would be the worst case scenario, experts said.

But, while it would be disastrous at a local level, they explained it wouldn't have a major impact on Europe more widely.

"The main danger here is damage to the systems needed to keep the fuel in the reactor cool – external power lines, emergency diesel generators, equipment to dissipate heat from the reactor core," Acton said.

"In a war, repairing this equipment or implementing countermeasures could be impossible. In the worst case, the fuel could melt and spread large amounts of radioactivity into the environment."

An attack on structures used to store spent nuclear fuel – fuel which is removed after use in a reactor – also poses a risk, with the potential to release radioactive material into the surrounding area. But, experts said, it wouldn't travel far.

The head of Energoatom, Petro Kotin, said one strike earlier in August was close to the processed fuel storage area. "This is very dangerous, because the rockets hit 10 to 20 meters away from the storage, but if they had hit the containers with the processed fuel, it would be a radiation accident," Kotin said on Ukrainian television.

If one container is hit, "it will be a local accident on the territory of the plant and nearby territory. If it's two to three containers, the affected area will increase," he added.

How is Zaporizhzhia different to Chernobyl?

Shelling around Zaporizhzhia has triggered warnings of another "Chernobyl" — the world's worst-ever nuclear disaster.

But there are numerous differences between the two Ukrainian power plants and experts insist that a repeat of the 1986 cataclysm is essentially impossible.

The Chernobyl plant used Soviet-era, graphite-moderated RBMK reactors, which lacked a modern containment structure – a concrete and steel dome designed to prevent any release of radiation.

In contrast, each of the six reactors at the Zaporizhzhia facility are pressurised water reactors encased in a massive steel vessel, housed in a concrete containment building. The design is called VVER, the Russian acronym for water-water-energetic reactor.

"The brakes on these kinds of reactors are much much better," Cizelj said. "If there would be damage to these reactors, it would be much easier to shut it down."

The scale of a hypothetical nuclear meltdown would also be far smaller than that of Chernobyl, experts said. After the 1986 meltdown, radioactive fallout scattered across much of the northern hemisphere, while some 150,000 square kilometres in Belarus, Russia and Ukraine were contaminated, according to the IAEA. That contamination spread as far as 500km north of the site.

Experts instead suggest that the feasible worst-case would look more like another, more recent disaster.

"Fukushima is a better analogy than Chernobyl," Acton said. "In this event, evacuations may be required for tens of kilometres around the plant, especially downwind. In the middle of a war those would be exceptionally dangerous."

Any radioactive fallout would spread around 10km or 20km from Zaporizhzhia before it would cease to pose serious health risks, experts suggest.

"If somebody was able to cause the meltdown of the reactors, (gases) could escape in the atmosphere and the would travel with the wind until they are washed out of the atmosphere," Cizelj said. "With distance, dilution happens – so very soon, the dilution becomes sufficient that the impact becomes not very serious for the environment and for people's health."

But for people living in war-torn southern Ukraine, a nuclear disaster is not the most immediate danger. "If you compare it to the other risks they are facing, this risk is not very large," he added.

Peter Dutton calls for 'discussion' on nuclear power in Australia

Opposition Leader Peter Dutton has called for a discussion on the introduction of nuclear power in Australia.

Dutton floated the idea in a tweet.

"Peak business groups and unions are calling for the moratorium on nuclear power to be lifted, amid a push to ensure Australia is 'technology agnostic' during its transition to cut emissions," he said.

READ MORE: Morrison responds to flood of secret jobs memes with his own attempt

Peter Dutton has called for a discussion about nuclear power in Australia.

"It's time to have the discussion."

Australia has never had a nuclear power station, though several have been proposed since the 1950s.

While nuclear energy has been opposed on environmental grounds for decades, the prospect of consistent baseload power and zero carbon emissions has led to increasing calls to consider it.

LIVE UPDATES: Bowen announces electric car requirement for importers

A nuclear power facility in Germany. Fossil fuel is still the undisputed energy king.

In 2013, then-Prime Minister Tony Abbott also floated the idea of nuclear power in Australia.

"Nuclear power is the only proven way of generating the baseload power Australia needed without producing carbon pollution," he said.

About a third of the world's uranium is mined in Australia.

Help! I bought a second-hand car that's a lemon

Every week we will break down, debunk and demystify your rights as a shopper in Australia. This week we are looking at what consumer protections there are for buying second-hand cars privately.

We all know life is getting more expensive than ever before, and how important it is to stretch every dollar you make.

That's why each week we'll answer a question surrounding what shoppers are – and aren't – entitled to when dealing with retailers and manufacturers.

MONEY MATTERS: Is it legal for shops to offer discounts for cash?

DUD IN THE DRIVEWAY

Hi Stu,

Last year I bought a cheap Subaru second-hand from a guy online and it all appeared to be fine – drove okay, all the papers and everything were in order.

Barely a week after I had it, it started playing up on me and blowing lots of white smoke and losing heaps of power. My mechanic said it needs a new head gasket which could cost $2000.

I was really annoyed by this considering I only paid $2500 for the car! Do I have any consumer protections to get my money back?

Hi there, sorry to hear about the car – I myself have always run cheap dodgy cars and know the feeling well.

The short answer to your question is no. 

When buying a car privately (and not from a licensed motor dealer) the onus is on the buyer to do the required checks. There are no dealer guarantees if you buy a car privately from someone.

MONEY MATTERS: Refund loophole most consumers have no idea about

Under Australian Consumer Law, the seller of the car is required to ensure that the vehicle has a clear title.

Even then I would be extremely cautious and run the appropriate Personal Property Securities Register (PPSR) check for the car. It costs just $2 and will tell you if it's been written off, stolen or has money owing on it.

It's always advised that you get an independent mechanic to check the car you're about to buy. 

Yes it costs money, but for the same cost as a tank of fuel (at least in today's prices) you could save yourself some major headaches.

MONEY MATTERS: Can a business refuse legal tender in Australia?

It's also important to remember that cars are a mass of moving parts. Despite the best intentions of manufacturers, cars can and do breakdown – sometimes soon after they are sold.

Fundamentally when buying a car privately caveat emptor – buyer beware – applies. 

This is why it's generally cheaper to buy a car from a private person rather than a licensed motor dealer, who by law must give some consumer protections.

The situation with your Subaru sucks, but I would take it as a $2500 life lesson.

Do you have a consumer question you want answered? You can get in touch with reporter Stuart Marsh at sm****@******om.au.

The information provided on this website is general in nature only and does not constitute personal financial or legal advice. The information has been prepared without taking into account your personal objectives, financial situation or needs. Before acting on any information on this website you should consider the appropriateness of the information having regard to your objectives, financial situation and needs.

Apple warns of serious security flaw for iPhones, iPads and Macs

Apple has disclosed serious security vulnerabilities for iPhones, iPads and Macs that could potentially allow attackers to take complete control of these devices.

Apple released two security reports about the issue on Wednesday, although they didn’t receive wide attention outside of tech publications.

Apple’s explanation of the vulnerability means a hacker could get “full admin access" to the device.

READ MORE: Families trapped for hours on motorway after deadly crash

That would allow intruders to impersonate the device's owner and subsequently run any software in their name, said Rachel Tobac, CEO of SocialProof Security.

Security experts have advised users to update affected devices — the iPhone6S and later models; several models of the iPad, including the 5th generation and later, all iPad Pro models and the iPad Air 2; and Mac computers running MacOS Monterey.

The flaw also affects some iPod models.

Apple did not say in the reports how, where or by whom the vulnerabilities were discovered. In all cases, it cited an anonymous researcher.

READ MORE: Nurse urges people not to ignore symptoms after bowel cancer diagnosis

Girl using device online iPad

Commercial spyware companies such as Israel’s NSO Group are known for identifying and taking advantage of such flaws, exploiting them in malware that surreptitiously infects targets’ smartphones, siphons their contents and surveils the targets in real time.

NSO Group has been blacklisted by the U.S. Commerce Department.

Its spyware is known to have been used in Europe, the Middle East, Africa and Latin America against journalists, dissidents and human rights activists.

READ MORE: Finnish PM denies drug intake during 'wild' dance party

Apple iPhone 13

Security researcher Will Strafach said he had seen no technical analysis of the vulnerabilities that Apple has just patched.

The company has previously acknowledged similarly serious flaws and, in what Strafach estimated to be perhaps a dozen occasions, has noted that it was aware of reports that such security holes had being exploited.

REVIEW: Opel Mobile Smart Kids, putting control in the hands of parents