Tag Archives: oceania

Extortion plot last straw before mum's death, lawyers say

An extortion plot for $100,000 over a false rape allegation was the last straw for the man defence lawyers say really killed Melbourne mum Ellie Price.

The 26-year-old was found dead from horrific stab injuries in the bedroom of her South Melbourne apartment on May 4, 2020.

Her boyfriend Ricardo Barbaro is standing trial for murder in the Victorian Supreme Court.

READ MORE: Qantas sorry for sacking 1700 workers illegally

But his barrister, Rishi Nathwani, says the evidence means jurors can't rule out brothel owner Mark Gray may have arranged for someone to kill her, and therefore must acquit.

Jurors heard Price had tried to extort Gray, the sugar daddy who paid for her apartment, car, clothes and a $2000 weekly allowance.

Gray told the court in two days of evidence during Barbaro's trial that he didn't want anything in exchange for all he provided, but Nathwani asked jurors if common sense and life experience backed that claim.

"Imagine getting all that given to you and going to find somebody else," he read from texts Gray sent to Price's sister Danielle after her death.

"At the end of the day she was replacing me with this guy… I was always the bridesmaid and never the bride."

Nathwani said the relationship between Gray and Price was one-way and it was clear Gray was getting upset and frustrated.

"This was the final straw for him," he said of the extortion plot.

The brothel owner risked losing his licence to operate his businesses if a rape allegation was made, the barrister said

"After years of being shunned, she went after his business."

READ MORE: Millionaire developer says unemployment needs to be much higher

Gray had also professed to know some of the "meanest people in Melbourne" and had himself, more than two years ago, suggested defence would claim at trial that he had hired a hitman to kill Price because of the extortion plot.

Barbaro was arrested in NSW days after Price's death, after first travelling to Canberra.

Prosecutors suggested he fled the state to avoid being detected by police. But Nathwani said he didn't leave the state until May 5 – a day after Price's body was found and six days after it's believed she was killed.

He also questioned why a person running from the police would rent a van in their own name, using their driver's licence, from their father's employer as Barbaro had.

"It comes right back to you," he said. He suggested it was not unreasonable Barbaro, like his family, also had a mistrust of police given he had two brothers die with some police involvement.

Prosecutor Damien Hannan said in his closing address on Tuesday that defence had posed this case as a whodunnit, with Gray a distraction from the real issues of the trial.

But Nathwani suggested at the end of their deliberations jurors could not conclude Gray might not have been involved.

"Whodunnit? The distraction," he said.

Justice Lex Lasry will direct jurors on matters of law before they begin their deliberations.

Accused rapists, sex offenders to be named as state changes law

People charged with rape and other sexual offences in Queensland can soon be named after new laws passed in the state today.

The laws will commence on October 3, meaning the identity of accused rapists and sex offenders can be reported.

Here's what we know about the changes.

READ MORE: Qantas sorry for sacking 1700 workers illegally

Brisbane Supreme Court, Queensland Supreme Court, Brisbane District Court, Queensland District Court.

What has changed?

The changes are to the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act 1978 which currently prohibits media from reporting the identity of accused rapists or defendants facing charges for "prescribed sexual offences".

A prescribed sexual offence refers to rape, attempt to commit rape, assault with intent to commit rape and sexual assault.

Previously, the law meant the identity of the accused in a sexual assault case couldn't be published until they were committed to stand trial.

The Queensland parliament passed an update to the act on Wednesday, meaning alleged rapists or sex offenders can be publicly named in the media before they stand trial.

Soon, those accused of sexual offences will be treated the same as people charged with any other offence.

READ MORE: Millionaire developer says unemployment needs to be much higher

The only way their identity is protected is if the accused, victim or prosecution apply to a court for a non-publication order.

But the application for a non-publication order will be scrutinised extensively with the court considering submissions made and views expressed by an alleged victim.

Accredited media will also be able to attend any hearings on a non-publication order application.

When does it start?

The legislation takes effect from October 3.

From that date, the accused's identity can be published with the only exception being if revealing the name would subsequently identify the victim.

What does it mean?

Justice and Prevention of Domestic and Family Violence Minister Yvette D'Ath said the changes put the interest of victims at the forefront of the judicial system.

"Rape and sexual assault are some of the most underreported criminal offences in Australia and we want to support victims to come forward and hold perpetrators to account," she said.

"Rape and sexual assault are some of the most underreported criminal offences in Australia and we want to support victims to come forward and hold perpetrators to account."

What are the laws around Australia?

The changes to Queensland laws bring the state closer in line with other states and territories except for the Northern Territory.

READ MORE: Ship full of Australians stranded at sea

Melbourne's County Court.

In New South Wales, the complainant can't be identified unless there is permission by the court but the defendant can be identified without the court's permission.

In the ACT, the defendant can be identified but the complainant can't be identified by name "reference or allusion including allowing someone to find out their private, business or official address, email address or telephone number".

In South Australia, alleged rapists can be named from their first court appearance as long as it doesn't in any way identify the alleged victim.

In Western Australia, the identity of accused rapists can be published.

In Victoria, an accused sex offender can be identified.

In the Northern Territory, an accused rapist cannot be identified until after they're committed to stand trial.

Support is available from the National Sexual Assault, Domestic Family Violence Counselling Service at 1800RESPECT (1800 737 732).

Third teenager charged over alleged abduction of Melbourne schoolboy

A third teenager has been charged over the alleged abduction and armed robbery of a schoolboy in Melbourne's east last week.

A 14-year-old boy was walking home with three friends when he was allegedly confronted by a group in a Volkswagen Tiguan about 3.35pm last Monday.

He was allegedly forced into the car, which drove along Neerim Road before he fell out in unknown circumstances near the intersection of Grange Road and sustained significant injuries.

READ MORE: Police hunt for culprit after sleeping boy was shot in Melbourne

Police arrested a 14-year-old girl this morning in Langwarrin.

She has been charged with multiple offences including dangerous driving, armed robbery and theft of a motor vehicle.

The girl has been bailed to appear at a children's court at a later date.

Two boys, aged 14 and 15, have also been charged over the incident.

'Who is going to believe me?': Historical abuse exposed in racing industry report

Reports of sexual harassment, bullying and physical abuse has gone unchecked over the past 50 years in the Victorian racing industry, a report has found.

Racing Integrity Commissioner Sean Carroll released an "extensive and confronting" 78-page independent review into the industry on Wednesday.

The review heard "devastating accounts of physical and sexual abuse of people across decades, including children and young recruits in the industry".

READ MORE: Police hunt for culprit after sleeping boy was shot in Melbourne

"The abuse involves rape, other forms of sexual and physical assault, humiliating initiation practices, ritualised violence, grooming and harassment, including in recent years. Some of this abuse was perpetrated against children as young as 12," the report said.

Brutal initiation rituals were found to be considered "normal practice" and "right of passage in many stables", according to the review.

This included being whipped on the genitals, being burnt with hoof oil or shoe polish, or being locked in the boot of a car for hours.

"These practices ranged from, what some called, 'just a bit of fun' to rape, sexual abuse and serious physical assaults," the report said.

"All victim survivors who spoke of being the target of initiations – and who knew of others who were similarly besieged – were minors at the time, no older than 15 years of age, and many were younger."

READ MORE: Third person charged over Melbourne man's death in July

Historical harm was uncovered as far back as the 1970s, with 80 per cent of victims subjected to harm in their first three years in the industry.

Racing Victoria chief executive Andrew Jones said the report provided accounts of experiences that "no-one should be subjected to".

"While the review covered all three codes, it is clear there were unacceptable practices in the thoroughbred racing industry," he said.

"And while the industry has come a long way, there are still issues to deal with. We thank sincerely those who had the courage to come forward and share their experiences.

"We acknowledge the harm suffered and, on behalf of the industry, apologise for it."

READ MORE: Qantas outsourcing of more than 1600 jobs in pandemic ruled illegal

Australian Trainers' Association chief executive Andrew Nicholl said the report was "stark" and troubling.

"We echo the sentiments expressed by RV: no one would disagree one victim of physical or sexual abuse, assault or harassment is one too many," he said.

"It is also clear the ATA, an industry body representing licensed trainers, has a vital role to play helping educate our members on their responsibilities as employers.

"Employees, as a basic right, must feel safe, secure and supported in their workplace – anything less is simply unacceptable."

Harness Racing Victoria along with Greyhound Racing Victoria also offered an apology.

READ MORE: Apple announces radical changes for iPhone 15

The commissioner outlined nine recommendations in the report, including the establishment of independent schemes for current and former industry participants who have experienced physical and sexual abuse or harassment.

"The dark flipside of loyalty has been a culture of silence across the industry that is underpinned by an historical and widespread, tacit discouragement of reporting," Carroll said.

"At times, those who have raised complaints have been the subject of overt retaliation. A number hold the perception that perpetrators of abuse have been protected."

Carroll expected action on several of his recommendations within the next 12 months.

Support is available from the National Sexual Assault, Domestic Family Violence Counselling Service at 1800RESPECT (1800 737 732).