Tag Archives: oceania

Voice architects bullish as referendum support drops under majority

Some of the leading architects of the proposed Indigenous Voice to Parliament have urged Australians to keep the faith even as support for the body has slid below majority levels for the first time.

According to a Resolve poll published in the Sydney Morning Herald yesterday, three states (WA, SA and Queensland) would vote "no" in the referendum if it was held today, while only 49 per cent of Australians would cast a ballot in favour of the constitutional change.

Responding to the poll, Pat Anderson and Megan Davis, the co-chairs of the Uluru Dialogue, said they remain heartened by their meetings with people around the country.

READ MORE: What is the Indigenous Voice to parliament and what would a referendum entail?

Uluru Dialogue co-chairs Professor Megan Davis and Pat Anderson sign the Uluru Statement from the Heart.

"The Uluru Dialogue takes its biggest cues from the countless meetings and conversations we're having on the ground with both First Nations people and non-Indigenous Australians – the very people to whom the Uluru Statement was issued as an invitation to walk together," they said.

"We're so heartened by those conversations with regards to recognition through a Constitutionally enshrined Voice, and our faith in the Australian people remains as strong as ever."

Support for the Voice, according to Resolve, has dropped from 64 per cent last September, and has fallen by nine per cent in the last three months alone, leading to calls for the Yes campaign to undergo an overhaul before this year's vote.

READ MORE: 'Shocked', 'saddened': Outpouring of grief as bus victims named

Prime Minister Anthony Albanese reveals the wording of the question to be asked on the referendum to establish an Indigenous Voice to parliament.

Anderson and Davis, however, said outlining the nature and benefits of the proposed advisory body was a compelling argument.

"We are finding that when we sit down with people and explain the difference that the Voice will make – where so many other initiatives and ideas devised within the Canberra bubble have failed – they are more than ready to vote Yes," the co-chairs said.

"A First Nations Voice will make the difference between the completely unacceptable status quo and a brighter, more optimistic future.

READ MORE: 'Those are the facts': Katy Gallagher denies misleading parliament

"A successful referendum based upon openness and respect will unify the nation.

"Keep the faith… history is calling."

Noel Pearson, another one of the Voice's architects, yesterday called for the Voice's proponents to focus more on the importance of reconciliation and constitutional recognition, rather than the Voice itself, to boost the referendum's chances of passing.

The Senate still needs to vote on the wording of the referendum this fortnight before a date for the vote is set.

Any referendum requires a majority of both people and states to vote in favour of the constitutional amendment for it to pass.

Sign up here to receive our daily newsletters and breaking news alerts, sent straight to your inbox.

'Those are the facts': Katy Gallagher denies misleading parliament

Katy Gallagher has once again denied misleading parliament over her knowledge of Brittany Higgins' rape allegations, while the Australian Federal Police is assesing a complaint over the leaking of text messages in the matter.

In a statement to the Senate, the federal finance minister repeated her assertion that, while she knew about Higgins' rape allegations before they became public, she had not misled parliament by telling an estimates committee three years ago that "no one had any knowledge" of the matter.

"At Senate estimates on June 4 2021, the then-minister for defence, Senator (Linda) Reynolds, said, 'I know where this started'," Gallagher said.

READ MORE: Bus driver released on bail after deadly Hunter Valley crash

Katy Gallagher gives a statement to the Senate.

"She went on to say, 'I was told by one of your senators two weeks before about what you were intending to do with the story in my office'.

"Two weeks before.

"I was shocked at the assertion made by Senator Reynolds, with the clear implication that I was responsible or had some involvement with making that story public.

"That was not true. It was never true. And I responded to that allegation by saying no one had any knowledge."

Gallagher also said she had explained her prior knowledge of the allegations to Reynolds in a private meeting two years ago, which Reynolds accepted.

READ MORE: Is Donald Trump about to go to jail? Your questions answered

Gallagher had revealed on Saturday that she did know about Higgins' allegations but insisted she had never misled parliament over the matter.

Reynolds is the minister in whose office Higgins claimed she was raped by then-Liberal staffer Bruce Lehrmann.

Lehrmann, who has always maintained his innocence, was charged over the allegations. His first trial was aborted without a finding due to juror misconduct, while a second was abandoned by prosecutors over concerns for Higgins' health.

A few hours after Gallagher's statement, Attorney-General Mark Dreyfus confirmed in Question Time that a complaint has been made to the AFP over the leaking of texts from the Lehrmann trial.

"I am deeply concerned about the apparent unauthorised publication of material produced as a result of a subpoena in the criminal trial of Mr Bruce Lehrmann," he told parliament.

"Material produced to a court in response to a subpoena is subject to an implied undertaking from the parties who receive it, that it won't be used for purposes other than for those court proceedings… to breach it may constitute a contempt of court.

"I do understand that the Australian Federal Police have received a complaint in respect of this matter and that the AFP is currently assessing that complaint.

"It's vital that victims of alleged sexual assault have confidence that if they come forward and report what happened to them they will be treated fairly by our justice system."

READ MORE: Charges upgraded to murder after Perth officer dies in hospital

Scott Morrison remains a member of parliament.

Gallagher wasn't the only politician to defend their actions over their handling of Higgins' allegations in parliament today.

Former prime minister Scott Morrison also denied he misled the house after being accused of doing just that by Reynolds' former chief of staff, Fiona Brown.

In an interview with The Australian over the weekend, Reynolds' former chief of staff, Fiona Brown, accused Morrison of telling parliament he had talked to her about Higgins' allegations when they had not.

While Morrison admitted that Brown's version of events may be more accurate than his own, the former PM insisted he had never deliberately misled the chamber.

While my recollection differed to that of Ms Brown, given there's more than two years that have passed… while I believe my response to accurate at the time, I cannot obviously fully discount her recollection of those events now were the more accurate," Morrison said.

"However, I reject any suggestion of deliberate intent in any such possible inaccuracy to my response."

Readers seeking support can contact Lifeline on 13 11 14 or beyond blue on 1300 22 4636.

Suicide Call Back Service 1300 659 467.

Support is available from the National Sexual Assault, Domestic Family Violence Counselling Service at 1800RESPECT (1800 737 732).

Sign up here to receive our daily newsletters and breaking news alerts, sent straight to your inbox.

Judge wrong to award $1.5m to Bill Spedding, court told

A $1.5 million award to Bill Spedding over trumped-up historical sexual assault allegations brought during the investigation into William Tyrrell's disappearance should be overturned, an appeals court has been told.

The State of NSW was ordered to pay Spedding the $1.5 million in December last year after police maliciously prosecuted the washing machine repairman while looking into the three-year-old's whereabouts in September 2014.

NSW Supreme Court Justice Ian Harrison found NSW Police and the Director of Public Prosecutions continued the case against Spedding, in which made-up claims of historical sexual abuse against two girls were brought, for an improper purpose.

READ MORE: What we know about the fatal Hunter Valley wedding bus crash

Bill Spedding leaves the Queens Square Supreme Court after successfully suing the NSW POLICE for wrongful arrest related to the William Tyrrell case. Photo Nick Moir 1 Dec 2022

On Tuesday, NSW's barrister Stephen Free SC attempted to overturn this judgment, arguing that Harrison incorrectly analysed the facts of the case and made erroneous findings in favour of Spedding.

Free submitted that while the judge identified the three police officers who were investigating Spedding and who first charged him with sexual abuse, no one was named in the Office of the DPP over the claimed malicious prosecution.

"That kind of approach is apt to lead to error because it doesn't zero in on the particular act or particular individuals at particular times," he told the NSW Court of Appeal.

Without naming individuals in the ODPP, it was impossible to assess their state of mind and determine whether they maliciously pursued the case against Spedding, the court was told.

READ MORE: Bus driver granted bail over wedding crash

There was also no evidence to suggest the director or those under him were colluding with police officers, including Inspector Gary Jubelin who openly wrote that the criminal proceedings were a way to nail Spedding for William's disappearance.

"(As) the person leading the investigation, I had to weigh up the cost of charging Bill against the cost of doing nothing and found the scales did not balance. The cost of doing nothing was heavier," he wrote in his book, I Catch Killers.

There was no evidence that Jubelin was the critical decision-maker when it came to charging Spedding, Free said.

There was also nothing to say that the other police officers working on the case or the officers at the ODPP shared Jubelin's ulterior motive, the barrister added.

Harrison also erred by finding the DPP was not reasonable in bringing the sexual assault charges against Spedding in April 2015 or for continuing with the case.

Prosecutors were not required to read over other material available to NSW Police which showed the charges were made-up and were entitled to bring the matter to trial, despite a not guilty verdict eventually being handed down in March 2018.

"It's not the role of the prosecutor to usurp the function of a jury," Free said.

The hearing continues.

Sign up here to receive our daily newsletters and breaking news alerts, sent straight to your inbox.

Death of man in Perth home being treated as suspicious

Homicide detectives are investigating after a man was found dead inside his home in Perth's north-east.

The grim discovery was made by a person known to the man who visited the Diana Crescent address in Lockridge about 3.45pm yesterday.

WA Police Inspector Geoff DeSanges said police were treating the death as suspicious.

READ MORE: Murder charge for man accused of running over Perth police officer

DeSanges said investigations would continue.

"There are circumstances that are evident at the crime scene that give us rise to suspect there was third-party involvement," he said.

"This does not appear to be a random incident, so we don't believe there's any ongoing risk to the community.

"However, we're asking anyone to come forward who may know something about it."

Sign up here to receive our daily newsletters and breaking news alerts, sent straight to your inbox.